Explore how silicone, saline and gummy bear implants differ in feel, shape and monitoring, and how your anatomy helps guide the choice.
Choosing an implant is one of the first decisions in breast augmentation. There is no single choice that suits everyone. Each option behaves differently in the body, and the choice depends on your frame, your existing breast tissue and the look you have in mind.
If you are comparing silicone vs saline implants, it helps to understand where gummy bear implants fit, too. This guide explains the three options offered at LuxYou Plastic Surgery in Long Beach, in the order patients most often ask about them.
A silicone implant has a silicone shell filled with soft silicone gel. Because the gel moves much like natural breast tissue, many patients find that it feels more natural, especially when they have little breast tissue of their own to cover the implant.
Silicone implants arrive prefilled, so the incision is usually a little longer than for saline. They come in a wide range of sizes, profiles and shapes, allowing your surgeon to consider both the width of your chest and the amount of forward projection you want.
"Gummy bear" is the everyday name for a highly cohesive silicone gel implant, so it is a type of silicone implant rather than a separate filling material. The firmer gel holds its shape, much as a gummy candy does when cut. These implants are often teardrop shaped, with more fullness at the bottom than at the top.
Because the gel is form-stable, gummy bear implants may be less prone to rippling or folding than other types. The trade-off is a slightly firmer feel. A shaped implant also needs to remain in the intended position, which makes careful surgical planning especially important.
A saline implant has a silicone shell that is placed empty and then filled with sterile salt water. Filling it after placement allows it to pass through a smaller incision. The amount of saline can also be adjusted slightly to help with symmetry between your breasts.
Saline tends to feel firmer and can show rippling when there is little tissue covering the implant. If it leaks, the breast visibly deflates and your body harmlessly absorbs the salt water. That visible change usually makes a leak easier to recognize than one in a gel implant.
Feel. Soft silicone gel generally offers the softest, most tissue-like feel. Gummy bear implants are firmer and hold their shape, while saline tends to feel the firmest of the three. Your own tissue coverage also affects how an implant feels.
Shape. Conventional silicone and saline implants are typically round. Gummy bear implants are often teardrop shaped, which may appeal to you if you prefer a sloped upper breast. Shape is one part of the choice, alongside your anatomy and desired fullness.
Incision. Saline generally needs the smallest incision because it is filled in place. Prefilled gel implants need a slightly longer opening. The incision is most often placed in the crease under the breast, where it can be less noticeable.
Monitoring. A saline leak usually causes visible deflation, while a gel implant leak can be "silent," without an obvious change. The FDA recommends periodic imaging with ultrasound or MRI for silicone gel implants. Your surgeon will explain the monitoring schedule that applies to you.
The implant is only one part of your surgical plan. Placement above or below the chest muscle affects how it looks and feels. Under-muscle placement provides more coverage and is often considered when you have less breast tissue. Over-muscle placement does not disturb the muscle and may allow a slightly shorter recovery.
Implant volume is measured in cubic centimeters rather than cup sizes, and its width needs to suit the width of your rib cage. Trying implants during a consultation can make those measurements more meaningful than a number on a page. It also gives you a way to discuss proportion rather than size alone.
Whether it’s the breasts, face or body, it’s always about harmony and balance; you can’t isolate one element from the others. Dr. Garrett Wirth
No breast implant is a lifetime device. Implants can last many years, but most patients will have another operation at some point to replace an implant, change size or address changes in the breast. Capsular contracture, when scar tissue tightens around an implant, is one of the more common reasons. Treatment may involve breast revision or capsulectomy.
If your breasts have also dropped, an implant alone will not provide the lift needed to correct that drooping. A breast augmentation with lift may be more appropriate. A consultation can help clarify whether your goals involve adding volume, lifting the breasts or both.
At LuxYou Plastic Surgery, Dr. Garrett Wirth, a Board Certified plastic surgeon, reviews your measurements, tissue and goals with you before recommending an implant type, size and placement. The breast augmentation before and after gallery shows patients with different frames and choices, offering a starting point for discussing your preferences rather than predicting your result.
When you are ready to explore breast augmentation in Long Beach, book a consultation to talk through your questions. Our guide to what to know before breast augmentation can help you prepare for that conversation.